‘Joker’ Sends In The Clown But Doesnt Know What To Say About Him

Arthur Fleck takes seven psych meds. He laughs uncontrollably, a piercing cackle that ascends to the heavens (or descends to hell). When he dances, it’s with his gangly arms outstretched and his torso hunched in a manic daze. He has an affinity for clown makeup and a co-dependent relationship with his frail mother. He wants to be a stand-up comedian but doesn’t understand jokes. When people aren’t ignoring him, they’re pulverizing him. His stunted development is punished by a world that doesn’t sympathize with mental illness. Arthur Fleck wants to die.

But then a friend gives him a gun — it’s Gotham City (aka New York City) in 1981, when crime and chaos are relentless; gotta protect yourself out there — and suddenly Arthur springs to life in a way he hasn’t before. His ensuing transgressions make the evening news, and Arthur feels seen. He rebrands himself The Joker, becoming a hero to heathens who’d rather light the streets on fire than seek peace. 

Arthur is a movie character, but he could very well be somebody who appears on the actual evening news, one of the many mass shooters or riotous incels who have exposed America’s vile ethos. He is burdened, scorned, moonstruck. It’s for this reason that “Joker,” an origin story about the most famous villain from the “Batman” canon, is convinced of its own importance, even if its director, Todd Phillips (“The Hangover”), insists it is “not a political film.” 

Here’s the thing (oh boy, there are so many things): The Joker did not need an origin story. Most villains don’t. Michael Myers is terrifying because the original “Halloween” offers little insight about what prompts his killing spree; Darth Vader was superior before his dark night of the soul resulted in vicious lava burns. And The Joker, so effectively ghoulish when portrayed as deranged anarchists by Jack Nicholson (“Batman”) and Heath Ledger (“The Dark Knight”), is more convincing without all the mama drama. 

Joaquin Phoenix in “Joker.”

When we first meet Arthur (a gaunt Joaquin Phoenix), he is seated at a vanity mirror applying white pancake makeup. It’s his job. He performs circus-clown routines at children’s hospitals and waves “Everything Must Go!” signs outside doomed businesses. When he appears without greasepaint, the contrast is stark. Talking to a state-assigned counselor (Sharon Washington) who asks stock questions about his well-being, Arthur is pale and skeletal, his face lined with gloominess. “The worst part about having a mental illness is people expect you to behave as if you don’t,” his journal reads.

An introduction this empathetic hints at a complex psychodrama that never arrives. Phillips, who co-wrote the script with Scott Silver (“8 Mile”), demonstrates necessary compassion and a grim stylistic verve ― part horror movie, part domestic ballad. That line about mental illness turns devastating when Arthur’s quasi-therapy appointments are terminated due to lack of funding. When a lonely man haunted by anguish loses his only semblance of support, where can he turn? But that’s also when the film squanders whatever it hopes to say about encroaching villainy, lost amid a jumble of Man Goes Insane clichés. 

Does anyone want movies based on comic books to be this humorless? That’s not a rhetorical question. I guess certain DC Comics fanatics will say a gritty screed is exactly what they want. But “Joker” has a hollow core, presenting Arthur as protagonist-turned-antihero without much nuance to guide the evolution. He greets his demons in the darkest of ways, discovering himself in the process. That discovery, an inferno of violence, results in an alarmingly celebratory image: The Joker, surrounded by disciples worshiping at the feet of their new god to a crescendoing score composed by Hildur Guðnadóttir (“Chernobyl”).  

Joaquin Phoenix in “Joker.”

“Joker,” which I caught last week at the Toronto International Film Festival, isn’t bad, per se. Defying the formula that makes most comic-book adaptations feel the same, much of it is accomplished. It oozes style, taking cues from “Taxi Driver,” “The King of Comedy” and “Shutter Island.” (Martin Scorese is a producer.) In a particularly engaging sequence, The Joker prances down a long outdoor staircase, his maroon and yellow suit gleaming against a bleak gray sky.

But often that style is outweighed by muddled subtext. Even after Arthur becomes a bonafide killer, nothing is all that scary, which makes the film disturbing in a manner Phillips probably didn’t intend. When Arthur stabs a guy in the neck, Gary Glitter’s “Rock and Roll” — a pumped-up anthem commonly heard at sporting events — thunders in response. When he suffocates someone, a lens flare erupts across the screen, as if to bathe him in warm sunlight. Is that what these murders are meant to convey? Some sort of existential breakthrough?

Much will be made of Phoenix’s performance, which had already yielded Oscar buzz. His body is bony to the point of looking sickly. His shoulder blades jut out at disturbing angles. His stomach is too concave for comfort. Frankly, it’s a lot. Screen actors tend to think that weight fluctuations equal transcendence, but that’s rarely the case. Phoenix is fascinating to watch, yet he relies on lunacy tropes that are fairly obvious. Having seen this character so many times now, including as recently as 2016’s dreadful “Suicide Squad” (in which he was played by Jared Leto), it’s clear how few dimensions of The Joker are left to explore. The supporting players — Robert De Niro, Zazie Beetz, Frances Conroy, Brett Cullen, Brian Tyree Henry, Marc Maron — can only add so much weight. A misguided rendition of Stephen Sondheim’s “Send in the Clowns” adds even less.

In giving Arthur Fleck a de facto hero’s journey, “Joker” must survive the litmus test that is modern cultural discourse. The movie, a guaranteed box-office powerhouse, will anger some people and excite others. Some have already called it dangerous, worried that juvenile admirers will see Arthur Fleck’s metamorphosis as a call to arms at a time when shootings are rampant in America. The suggestion seems overblown to me, but that doesn’t mean it’s not a complicated thing to reckon with.

What we’re left with is something that’s tamer than its fiercest detractors will declare and more sinister than its loudest groupies can grasp. It is, in the end, a whole lot of nothing. But in mainstream Hollywood today, nothingness sells. 

“Joker” opens in theaters Oct. 4.

Read more: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/joker-review-joaquin-phoenix-todd-phillips_n_5d7bfddfe4b00d6905988775

3,112 thoughts on “‘Joker’ Sends In The Clown But Doesnt Know What To Say About Him

  1. Час назад осматривал данные сети интернет, при этом к своему восторгу обнаружил восхитительный вебсайт. Гляньте: зеркало casino x . Для меня данный ресурс оказался очень неплохим. Всего хорошего!

  2. I have seen plenty of useful elements on your internet site about pcs. However, I’ve got the opinion that notebook computers are still less than powerful sufficiently to be a good selection if you often do projects that require lots of power, for example video modifying. But for website surfing, microsoft word processing, and majority of other prevalent computer work they are just great, provided you can’t mind the tiny screen size. Appreciate sharing your opinions.
    generic sildenafil

  3. Затеяв улучшение в наше пора приобрести дверные конструкции «для всякий стиль и колорит» не составит особого труда. Задабривать межкомнатную дверь недорого сообразно ценам производителя можно в нашей компании. Рассмотрим подробнее типы межкомнатных систем.
    Самые востребованные модели, различающиеся сообразно размерам: стандартные, двустворчатые, полуторные, многостворчатые. Самые стильные и современные из них двери-купе, полюбившиеся дизайнерами всего мира, благодаря своей многофункциональности. А дверные системы со стеклом либо глухие найдут эхо в каждом интерьере.
    «Гармошка» Складные Оптимальный вариант для эконом-класса. В недорогом загородном жилище часто используются ради ванной комнаты и туалета. Ведь их гегемония в привлекательной цене. Приобретать дешевые межкомнатные двери с коробкой можно для нашем сайте.
    Маятниковые. Чаще всего их устанавливают в местах общественного пользования. Возьмем, в офисных коридорах alias на входе в ресторан.
    Покупка комплекта любых моделей межкомнатных дверей на выбор в нашем каталоге товаров. Продажи межкомнатных дверей осуществляются в интернет-магазине перейти сообразно розничным и оптовым ценам.
    Разновидности по материалу. Ламинированные, ПВХ, экошпон, 3D-Graf. Недорогие по сравнению с натуральными моделями. Бытность этом влагостойкие и легко чистятся. Обладают хорошими шумоизоляционными свойствами, только главная изюминка в дизайне. Благодаря эластичному верхнему слою могут содержаться всякий формы и цвета через белого заранее самого темного. Для нашем сайте дозволено обещать нестандартную, и даже двухцветную дверь соответственно индивидуальным размерам.
    Натуральные. Из шпона. Сильно недорогой видимость из натуральных пород древесины. Легко реставрируются применительно сравнению с искусственными материалами. Натуральные из массива. Красивые, глянцевые, классические и современные модели исключительно из ценных пород древесины (сосна, беленый дуб, миланский орех, бук). Обладают лучшей звукоизоляцией. В нашей компании доступны качественные деревянные межкомнатные двери с замками сообразно оптимальной стоимости.
    Мы можем быстро и качественно изготовить межкомнатные двери из натурального дерева чтобы заказ недорого. В интернет-каталоге дозволительно накануне посмотреть и выбрать лучшие межкомнатные двери ради фото и раньше рассчитать их цены. Подробности сообразно телефону.

  4. (CNN) – Trendy blood on guidelines. The National Introduce against Clinical Eminence (AMICABLE) updated draft guidelines earlier this year and will issue ultimate guidance soon. Peak BP remains at from 140/90, distant from the female viagra pills and US where 130/80 is at the moment the dividing line. Anyhow treatment will be offered to people with a 16 chance of heart strike or flourish in the next decade as an alternative of a 21% chance so more people will be offered treatment and lifestyle advice.
    June 11, 2019 16:40

  5. (MyLondon) – Indulgent Bleeding and Bruising. Your liver makes the things that succour your blood clot. When it’s damaged, it can’t cause enough. You influence start to bleed surely and have irk stopping it. Or you muscle scratch easily. Divulge your dentist or other doctors in the vanguard you be enduring any generic viagra medical procedure. Treat cuts with prevail upon bandages and get to the doctor claim away. In an danger, you’ll travel platelets to replace what you lost and Vitamin K to ease your blood clot.
    Updated: June 22, 2019 9:39

  6. (NDTV) – Every lingering hepatitis C infection starts with an severe phase. Acute hepatitis C in the main goes undiagnosed because it hardly ever causes symptoms. When signs and symptoms are bonus, they may categorize jaundice, along with enervate, nausea, fever and muscle aches. Sensitive symptoms come forth undivided to three months after publishing to the virus and form two weeks to three months. Wise hepatitis C infection doesn’t always mature chronic. Some people reach-me-down online pharmacy canada no prescription healthy lifestyle legible HCV from their bodies after the sharp-witted time, an outcome known as extemporaneous viral clearance. In studies of people diagnosed with sharp HCV, rates of instinctive viral clearance take diversified from 15% to 25%. Critical hepatitis C also responds far to antiviral therapy.
    Updated: July 18, 2019 11:17

  7. (NY Times) – The American Fundamentals Association recommends haunt monitoring on all people with extraordinary blood difficulty to remedy the healthcare provider determine whether treatments are working. House monitoring (self-measured blood press) is not a substitute recompense routine visits to your physician. If you cause been prescribed medication to belittle your blood sway to viagra over the counter walmart, don’t ban entrancing your medication without consulting your doctor, even if your blood on readings are in the natural range during home ground monitoring.
    Updated: November 16, 2019 17:37

  8. The stew is with your accomplice, not YOU – It is profoundly important to take cognizance of that it takes two to tango. Apropos 30% of non-productive couples discover the problem is in their respective manful partners, whereas, take a nap 40% infertility factors are on both sides. Male infertility symptoms are viagra online canadian pharmacy less observable without getting a semen review done. This enquiry measures the vigour of semen and sperm. So, advance a gain access to your participant thoroughly checked if you don’t suss out any infertility tough nut to crack in your self. May 14, 2019 11:38

  9. a reaches the man’s reproductive darned in less than no time and help boosts the supply of blood near the penis. As a issue, after bewitching this hypnotic placid out-moded majority men are also able to validate erections in the service of a longer duration of canadian pharmacy time.

  10. (CNN) – On the other present, it also shows some weighty side effects and on their incidence reporting to a doctor at years is deeply essential. Uncompromising side effects signs of viagra without a doctor prescription are- abnormally miserable blood sway, increased intraocular compressing and permanent and painful erection owing more than 4 hours. Uncompromising a side effects are- nausea, diarrhea, unfeeling dizziness, and merciless difficulty, etc. Take these side effects greatly truly as they can be obsession imminent too. September – 26, 2019 13:18